The Bur Oak: A Meditation on a Tree and Time, Fathers, and Sons

By Nolan Marciniec

When I was grow­ing up, par­tic­u­lar­ly dur­ing my teenage years, my father used to coun­sel, All things in time.” 

Thir­ty years ago, he and I came upon an impres­sive stand of bur oaks (Quer­cus macro­carpa). He took a hand­ful of acorns and pot­ted them up, plant­i­ng the seedlings on my prop­er­ty two years lat­er. Today, the trees are more than 30 feet tall, mag­nif­i­cent spec­i­mens that delight me in all sea­sons. They remind me of my father and some­how seem to embody his val­ues, his way of look­ing at the world.

In the spring, the oak pro­duces male and female flow­ers on the same branch. The long and pen­dant catkins” are male. The Farmer’s Almanac advis­es plant­i­ng corn when oak leaves are the size of a mouse’s ear. In the sum­mer, the mature leaves are lobed and round­ed, glossy, wider at the top – and occa­sion­al­ly home to oak galls,” which, I am told, were once the source of ink. In the fall, the leaves turn a non­de­script brown but, unlike most oak leaves, do not hang on through the winter. 

In the fall, one can see the dis­tin­guish­ing fea­ture of the bur oak, a mossy” or fringed bur-like cap that cov­ers most of the acorn. But to my mind, the tree is most beau­ti­ful after the leaves have fall­en in the fall and win­ter because, with its spread­ing, gnarled, and twist­ed branch­es, it has that clas­sic spooky Hal­loween” look! 

The stems and bark of the tree are grey, cork-like, and deeply fur­rowed. The oak’s dis­tinc­tive bark makes it fire tol­er­ant and thus able to sur­vive the prairie fires caused by light­ning strikes or set by Native Amer­i­cans: fire is crit­i­cal in main­tain­ing the prairie’s eco­log­i­cal balance. 

Peri­od­i­cal­ly, in mast years,” my bur oaks pro­duce heavy crops of acorns. These attract squir­rels (of course) to the yard, but deer and jays and turkeys as well as, on one mem­o­rable occa­sion, a young black bear. The squir­rels duti­ful­ly bury the acorns in mulch and in the tilled soil of the veg­etable gar­den. Every year, I pot up the seedlings and give them away to fel­low gar­den­ers who have the room for these mas­sive trees, the fastest grow­ing of all the Amer­i­can oaks. The trees seem to thrive, even in the heavy clay soil I strug­gle with.

It may be rel­a­tive­ly uncom­mon to find the bur oak in New York State: my father had to resort to a field guide to iden­ti­fy the tree. How­ev­er, vis­i­tors to Lan­dis can view sev­er­al mature spec­i­mens in the Arboretum’s Oak Col­lec­tion. Bur oaks, a species of the more com­mon white oak, seem to be more preva­lent in the Mid­west, where they tow­er, silent sen­tinels, over the prairie in those areas that have been pre­served from development. 

The state­ly and soul­ful bur oaks that line the streets of Oak Park, Illi­nois, are descen­dants of the oak savan­na that pre-dat­ed the arrival of the Euro­peans. They are a beau­ti­ful and mon­u­men­tal com­ple­ment to the nature-inspired archi­tec­ture of Frank Lloyd Wright, whose build­ings are a hall­mark of this Chica­go sub­urb. Many of these trees were prop­a­gat­ed from sev­er­al 200 – 300 year-old native bur oaks as part of the His­toric Oak Prop­a­ga­tion Project.

Sev­er­al huge bur oaks must have been plant­ed years ago along one of the roads near my home. One of the trees has a met­al piece embed­ded in its trunk. I won­der if the orig­i­nal own­er of the near­by Wal­ter But­lers­bury home (1742) had a hand in plant­i­ng them. (The home, inci­den­tal­ly, also has a love­ly grove of ancient locusts.) 

The bur oaks in front of my house, on the prairie, and on the near­by road, seem to embody time. In nature, how­ev­er, time moves infi­nite­ly more slow­ly than in man’s world. The poet Rabindranath Tagore wrote that the one who plants trees, know­ing that he will nev­er sit in their shade, has at least start­ed to under­stand the mean­ing of life,” a valu­able les­son my father taught me, when 30 years ago, he plant­ed the trees in whose shade he would nev­er sit.

For fur­ther reading: 

Peat­tie, Don­ald Cul­ross. A Nat­ur­al His­to­ry of Trees of East­ern and Cen­tral North Amer­i­ca. Boston, MA, Hough­lin Mif­flin Com­pa­ny, 1948.

Tal­lamy, Dou­glas W. The Nature of Oaks: The Rich Ecol­o­gy of Our Most Essen­tial Native Trees. Port­land, OR, Tim­ber Press, 2021.


Summer 2021

Volume 39 , Number 2

Share this

The Latest from Landis

Jun 10, 2022 | Anne Donnelly

Don't Overlook Your Reciprocal Admissions Privilege

A sometimes overlooked benefit of your Landis Arboretum membership is the American Horticultural Society Reciprocal... read more

May 29, 2022

Scenes From the Spring Plant Sale

Thanks to our many wonderful volunteers, plant consignors, vendors, and customers, the Landis Signature Spring... read more

May 28, 2022 | Fred Breglia, Executive Director

From the Director’s Desk: Q&A, Part III

In this last Q&A session, I am focusing on leaf color change during the... read more

May 28, 2022 | Erin McKenna Breglia, Landis Gardener

From the Garden: Milkweeds for Monarchs!

Many people enjoy seeing butterflies in our Landis gardens. especially the monarch butterfly, Danaus... read more

May 28, 2022 | Anita Sanchez

Life and Death on the Lawn

It’s a beautiful summer day. You’ve finished your stack of books from the Landis... read more

May 28, 2022 | Amy Howansky

Chasing the Impossible: Deer-Proof Shrubs

As a professional horticulturalist and employee at a garden center, I am asked many questions... read more

News Archive