Don't Know When to Quit - The American Beech

By Anita Sanchez

Amer­i­can Beech, Fagus gran­di­fo­lia, is a mag­nif­i­cent tree,
sil­very-barked and ele­gant. The leaves are sharp-point­ed ovals with
scal­loped edges — pale green in spring, emer­ald in sum­mer, gold­en in

But in win­ter, beech leaves reveal an odd per­son­al­i­ty trait: they’re
stub­born. Long after most oth­er decid­u­ous trees have shed their col­or­ful
foliage, beech leaves keep hang­ing onto the branch. They lose their
autumn col­or, turn brown, shriv­el up — but stick stub­born­ly to the twig,
week after week, month after month. They just don’t know when it’s time
to quit.

The trait of keep­ing leaves after they’re dead is called marces­cence (a word that is sure­ly in the finals of all spelling bees.) Sev­er­al oth­er species of trees have this trait, too, most notably oaks, occa­sion­al­ly horn­beams and witch hazels. Why do some trees do this? The answer is…no one knows. As with most nature ques­tions, this one has as many answers as there are web­sites. Botanists hot­ly debate the rea­sons why some trees hold on to their leaves till spring.

Some botanists sug­gest that marces­cence is a habit that trees are in the process of los­ing. Per­haps they’re evolv­ing on the way from ever­green-ness to decid­u­ous­ness? Maybe some­day in the dis­tant future beech leaves will fall off like the maples and birch­es and all the rest.

Or is marces­cence an adap­ta­tion for sur­vival? Does it con­fer an advan­tage dur­ing bit­ter win­ters — a tiny bit of insu­la­tion against cold? Maybe the dead leaves act as a snow fence, trap­ping snowflakes near the twigs and pro­vid­ing an extra bit of moisture.

Often, marces­cent leaves are on small, young trees or on low­er branch­es of large trees. Per­haps the leaves lin­gered on the branch­es to pro­vide one last lit­tle bit of pho­to­syn­the­sis as the leaves above fell off.

Or maybe — this seems like­ly — it pro­tects twigs from win­ter munch­ing by deer. Maybe it dis­cour­ages insect dam­age. Or pro­tects buds against frost.

Or maybe the answer is all of the above. No one knows for sure.

Beech trees are in trou­ble these days in the North­east, bat­tling a plague called beech bark dis­ease. It’s caused by a tiny, soft-bod­ied bug called a scale insect (acci­den­tal­ly import­ed from Europe in the 1800s) that weak­ens the tree by feed­ing on the liq­uids of bark cells. The insect also spreads a dead­ly fun­gus from tree to tree. I’m see­ing the sad sight of more and more dead beeches.

But even with the dis­ease, indi­vid­ual trees can last a long time, send­ing out new shoots and branch­es, and leaves that hang on even when the game is up.

The brit­tle, dried beech leaves move in every breath of win­ter wind. They rat­tle and tap against each oth­er, mak­ing a sound that’s hard to describe. Chat­ter­ing teeth, per­haps? No, more like rain on the roof. Dis­tant cas­tanets. Or mice skit­ter­ing. What­ev­er the rea­son for those papery skele­tons of leaves, they are the music of winter.

Tap to view full size

Winter 2016

Volume 34 , Number 1

Share this

The Latest from Landis

Mar 14, 2023

Picturing Landis through the year

Scenic Landis Arboretum just begs to be captured by photographers, professionals and amateurs alike. Enjoy... read more

Mar 14, 2023

2022 Annual Report

View or Download read more

Mar 14, 2023 | Nolan Marciniec

Re-thinking Garden Pests

“When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything... read more

Mar 14, 2023 | Fred Lape, founder of the George Landis Arboretum

Barn Swallows

In this poem, Arboretum founder Fred Lape calls our attention to the “commonplace” miracle of... read more

Mar 14, 2023 | Anita Sanchez

Things Are Looking Up

Tree canopy -- Anita Sanchez Long ago I worked at a nature center, leading walks... read more

Mar 14, 2023 | Laurie Freeman

S-L-O-W Birding: A Primer for Beginners

Are you considering birding? Perhaps you’ve heard that birding is a great way to enjoy... read more

News Archive