Apples and Man: A Book Review

By Sam McClary

Apples & Man, by Fred Lape
Apples and Man, by Fred Lape

Apples and Man,” writ­ten by Arbore­tum founder Fred Lape and pub­lished in 1979, is an ode to the incred­i­ble genus Malus.. But it also pos­es a warn­ing about the grow­ing threat by the pro­lif­er­a­tion of new insec­ti­cides, fungi­cides, and herbicides. 

The genus Malus is an evo­lu­tion­ary suc­cess sto­ry, sprout­ing, grow­ing and thriv­ing in a wide vari­ety of habi­tats. The species that were native to North Amer­i­ca are almost unrec­og­niz­able from the fruit you see in the gro­cery store. They were small­er both in tree habit and fruit pro­duc­tion. The fruit was small, hard, sour and bit­ter! We know this group of apples as crabap­ples. They were a key com­po­nent of any small farm in the ear­ly US, being used to make alco­holic cider and a con­cen­trat­ed fruit spread. Apples became more eco­nom­i­cal­ly impor­tant as these set­tlers devel­oped new vari­etals, per­fect­ing them through graft­ing and selec­tion. These apples could be eat­en fresh, pressed into cider, fer­ment­ed into an alco­holic cider, or frozen into apple­jack. They quick­ly became an impor­tant com­mod­i­ty crop; com­mer­cial grow­ing of apples began on a large scale in the 20th Century.

The ubiq­ui­tous Deli­cious” apple is a case in point.“Delicious” was not quite what the name sug­gests: its fla­vor much less com­plex than ear­li­er vari­eties. But the tree was a huge improve­ment in yield and reli­a­bil­i­ty. And the fruit’s skin was tougher — mak­ing it excel­lent for keep­ing and ship­ping. Thus began a shift in taste away from old­er vari­eties, all for the ben­e­fit of large agribusi­ness. It is here, Lape inter­jects, where things get messy.”

The apple, now a full-blown com­mer­cial crop, began to require more and more upkeep in the form of fer­til­iz­ers, pes­ti­cides and oth­er chem­i­cals in stark con­trast to the hardy and robust apples that evolved along­side human­i­ty (think John­ny Apple­seed.). The fol­low­ing list of chem­i­cals is from the 1974 Spray Guide for Tree Fruits in East­ern Wash­ing­ton,” pub­lished by the Coop­er­a­tive Exten­sion Ser­vice of the Col­lege of Agri­cul­ture of Wash­ing­ton State Uni­ver­si­ty. All of these were to be applied at var­i­ous stages pri­or to a com­mer­cial apple being pur­chased by a con­sumer: Dield­rin, Parathion, Dodine, Elge­tol, Sevin, Guthion, Cap­tan, Thio­dan, Dipheny­lamine, Simazine, Paraquat, Ethrel, NAA , and Ethoxyquin. Had you looked at the list ten years pri­or, you would also see the rec­om­men­da­tion of three or four spray­ings of DDT

Fred Lape s book rais­es some seri­ous ques­tions about the future of the genus Malus. What will become of Eso­pus Spitzen­berg, Graven­stein, Blue Pear­main, and Black Oxford, among count­less oth­er old cul­ti­vars? Will we defer to the easy-to-mer­chan­dise stan­dard­iza­tion pre­ferred by com­mer­cial grow­ers? What about the health con­se­quences of chem­i­cal­ly sus­tained agri­cul­ture? Or will we redis­cov­er excit­ing heir­loom vari­etals and re-learn how to grow apples in accor­dance with nature instead of in oppo­si­tion to it? Apples and Man” posits that the answers are up to us. 

Fall 2023

Volume 41 , Number 3

Share this

The Latest from Landis

Mar 18, 2024

Landis Signature Spring Plant Book and Bake Sale

You don’t want to miss this! read more

Mar 18, 2024

Landis Houseplant Swap!

If you’re a houseplant lover, this event is for you! read more

Mar 11, 2024 | Anita Sanchez

A Shallow Dive into Vernal Pools

Spring is the time for water. First the icicles start to drip. Then the streams... read more

Mar 11, 2024 | Sam McClary

Never Underestimate Nature: Rejuvenating Old Apple Trees

While driving along country roads in the autumn, watching the falling leaves – I suddenly... read more

Mar 11, 2024 | Shayne Mitchell

News and Muse from the Bluebird Trail

I think it is safe to say that the Eastern bluebird is the favorite bird... read more

Mar 11, 2024 | Sue Tricario

Landis Membership Away from Home

A membership at the Landis Arboretum is your passport to over 360 public gardens and... read more

News Archive